Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Erlank Pienaar's avatar

I have often wondered where this metaphor originated, or how it came to be. It is most apt. I find it most interesting how we carry along with us into present life the past. The 'set and setting' of the lived experience at the time of origin is so far removed from us today as to be unimaginable. Almost. I experience 'the black dog' more as a pensive sad, heavy hearted dog than a dog on my back. After all, the 'dog' is there in us already. To me, the dog is a companion in my gloom, not associated with a/the cause as such... Well done. Thanks

Expand full comment
Straussy's avatar

I feel like I'm going mad. Surely the "black dog" is simply word play on "Melancholy" or, ehem, "Melan Collie". To make it absolutely clear "Melan" means "black" and "collie" is obviosly a breed of "dog". Thus "we used to make of it a sort of Byword or Hack Joke here at Streatham". It's just a joke. Trying to pin this on the Greeks is pure conjecture. Interestingly, the origin of "collie" is said to be "coal", due to the dog's black, though also white, colour.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts