It is my friend Jess’s birthday tomorrow,1 so today she’ll be making her traditional upside-down pineapple cake for the celebration. In honour of this I’ll be exploring the history of its key ingredient.
The pineapple (Ananas comosus) is indigenous to tropical South America, where it was domesticated by Native American peoples long before the Columbian Exchange. The origin of cultivated pineapples is a little uncertain. Traditional accounts point to the region around the Paraná–Paraguay river basin (in present-day southern Brazil, Paraguay and northern Argentina) as the pineapple’s original homeland This area is home to several wild relatives of Ananas. Modern genetic studies, however, suggest that the north-eastern areas of South America, especially the Guiana Shield, may have been the primary domestication centre.
Domesticated pineapple cultivation may have begun as far back as 6,000–10,000 years ago. Archaeological remains suggest that by around 1200–800 BCE pineapples were already being used or grown in parts of coastal South America, and by the time of European conquest in the late 15th century, pineapple cultivation was ubiquitous across the Neotropical Americas: it was grown from the lowlands of Central America and the Caribbean, through Amazonia, all the way south to Paraguay and the foothills of the Andes.
Domestication profoundly transformed the pineapple plant. Wild pineapples bear much smaller, seedy fruits, but indigenous peoples selectively bred plants for larger, sweeter, seedless fruits over many generations. The result was the cultivated pineapple, which is nearly seedless and must be propagated vegetatively (by planting shoots or crowns) rather than by seed. Through human selection, pineapples developed more numerous and bigger fruitlets (the ‘eyes’ on the rind) and a more robust morphology – shorter, broader leaves and a sturdier stem to store starch – yielding bigger, juicier fruit. Gonzalo Fernández de Oviedo in his Historia general y natural de las Indias (1535) wrote that:
It is true that it is not entirely unlike an artichoke, nor entirely free from spines, because upon its crown, at the top of the pineapple, grows a rough tuft of leaves, which greatly enhances its appearance.
Some have, besides this, another such tuft, and others two or more, close to the base of the fruit where it is joined to the stalk of the plant upon which it grows.
And for the planting of new plants and pineapples, these tufts serve as the seed or means of propagation of the fruit.
For if one takes the tuft growing upon the top of a pineapple, or any of the others attached near its base, and plants it in the earth to a depth of two or three finger-widths, leaving half the tuft exposed, it very readily takes root.
And within the period I have already described, each tuft develops into another such plant and produces another pineapple, just as I have said.
The Tupi–Guarani people of Brazil were among those who first cultivated the plant, calling it naná meaning ‘excellent fruit’. Through propagation clones of the parent plant were created, ensuring the retention of desirable traits like sweetness and lack of seeds. The ease by which this could be done helped the fruit spread rapidly from village to village. In fact, the very names for pineapple in dozens of Indigenous languages (variations of nana/ananás) spread along with the plant itself.
When the Europeans arrived in the Americas at the end of the 15th century2 they became immediately enamoured with this delicious fruit. The first European mention of them comes from 1493 when Columbus’s son reported in an account of the second voyage:
They also saw gourds and a certain fruit which resembled our green pine cones, although much larger, filled with firm flesh like that of a melon, and with a much more delicate fragrance and flavour. These fruits grow on plants resembling lilies or aloes, out in the fields, although those which are cultivated are better, as was subsequently discovered.
The extent of the Spanish infatuation with the pineapple is perhaps best conveyed by the words of Gonzalo Fernández de Oviedo y Valdés (1478–1557) who continued in his Historia general y natural de las Indias:
And if, through lack of colours or skill in drawing, I cannot convey what I should wish to express, let the fault be attributed to my judgement. For, to my eyes, this is the most beautiful fruit of all the fruits I have seen, the one with the finest fragrance and the finest flavour.
Its size and colour are remarkable. It is green, illuminated or tinged with a very rich yellow, and the more it ripens, the more yellow it becomes, gradually losing its greenness.
At the same time its fragrance grows stronger, exceeding that of the most perfect peaches, with something of the scent of quince. Indeed, quince is the fruit whose fragrance most closely resembles that of the pineapple.
Its flavour is better than that of peaches, and it is juicier.
The fruit is peeled all around and cut into round slices, or thin sections, or however the carver wishes, for whether cut lengthways or across, it has a fine texture and makes a handsome appearance when sliced.
As you can imagine European nobility, upon reading these accounts, were salivating at the prospect of tasting this incredible fruit. There was a problem though: they couldn’t. Pineapples would rot on the voyage across the Atlantic (there is a story that one survived the trip to be eaten by King Ferdinand II of Spain in 1494, but this is probably not accurate)3 and they couldn’t be grown in European climes. As Valdés goes on to explain:
Some pineapples have been taken to Spain, but very few arrive there.
And even when they do arrive, they cannot be perfect or good, because they must be cut while still green and allowed to ripen at sea, and in this way they lose their reputation.
I myself have tried to take some to Spain, but because the voyage did not go well and took many days, every one of them spoiled and rotted.
I also tried taking the crowns, and these too were lost.
It is a fruit suited only to this land, or to another that is at least not so cold as Spain.
It is likely that a few edible pineapples made it across the Atlantic in the 16th century – harvested unripened – and that pineapple preserved in sugar was also transported, but these were not the same as the freshly picked fruit. Meanwhile cultivation spread rapidly to Africa and South Asia where the climatic conditions were perfect for the crop. Until well into the 17th century pineapples were, in Europe, objects of extraordinary rarity and fascination. So much so that the presentation of one to King Charles II of England was deemed worth of being recorded in a work of art:
We know that the king was generous in sharing his fruit, as the diarist John Evelyn recorded in his entry for 19th August 1668:
I saw the magnificent entry of the French Ambassador Colbert, received in the banqueting house. I had never seen a richer coach than that which he came in to Whitehall. Standing by his Majesty at dinner in the presence, there was of that rare fruit called the king-pine, growing in Barbadoes and the West Indies; the first of them I had ever seen. His Majesty having cut it up, was pleased to give me a piece off his own plate to taste of; but, in my opinion, it falls short of those ravishing varieties of deliciousness described in Captain Ligon’s history, and others; but possibly it might, or certainly was, much impaired in coming so far; it has yet a grateful acidity, but tastes more like the quince and melon than of any other fruit he mentions.
Evelyn’s disappointment was due to his pineapple being ripened on its long sea journey, rather than on a living plant. For Europeans to properly experience the fruit it had to be grown and ripened on the continent itself. This problem was finally solved in 1687 by Dutch art collector and horticulturalist Agnes Block (1629–1704), as an 1854 biography recounted:
She became particularly renowned for her extraordinary passion for flowers and plants, and her country estate Vijverhof, where in 1687 she brought the first pineapple in these regions to full perfection.
Obviously to celebrate this she had a picture painted of herself admiring her pineapple plant (can you see a trend emerging here?).
There were two ways of achieving the temperatures required to grow this wonderful fruit. The simplest, in terms of design and construction, was to create a pine pit which relied upon the warmth of fermenting manure, as William Speechly, the head gardener of Welbeck Abbey, explains:
The Pine-apple Plant requires more heat, and a greater degree of humidity than almost any other vegetable of the same tribe, which grow in our stoves or hot-houses.
The pit is generally from four to six feet deep, and from five to eight feet wide, being built with brick, and the sides plastered; a central passage is left, and on each side the beds for the plants. The beds are heated underneath with fermenting dung, tan, or leaves. A frame and lights, like those of a common hot-bed, are placed over the pit, so as to receive the full rays of the sun.
These pits required constant attention, and in time they were replaced with pine stoves – greenhouses heated with, you guessed it, stoves, and later hot water. It was using such a system that, sometime around 1714, Henry Telende, a Dutch gardener employed by Matthew Decker, a Dutch-born English merchant, economist and politician, finally grew the first pineapple in England. What did Decker do to celebrate? He had a painting done of it. Obviously.
The cost of production was insanely high for these early pineapples, it has be said as much as £80 each,4 when a labourer might earn £105 a year (so hundreds of thousands of pounds or dollars in today’s terms). This scarcity and exoticness lead to something called ‘pineapple mania’, with the fruit being represented in art (as you have seen) on fabrics, china and buildings. When Christopher Wren was deciding what to put on top of the south-west tower of St Paul’s Cathedral the choice was obvious – a massive golden pineapple.

The best place to have architectural pineapples was, of course, on the specialist hothouse you had constructed to grow them. The apogee of this is the Dunmore Pineapple House, built in 1761 by John Murray, 4th Earl of Dunmore (1730–1809). Dunmore is perhaps better known as being the last British colonial governor of Virgina whose actions in 1775 and 1776 caused Southerners in general, and Virginians in particular, to solidify their opposition to British rule. But before all that he built the most amazing building in which to grow pineapples, and it stands to this day!

As the 18th century proceeded even though cultivation techniques improved pineapples were still astonishingly rare. Amelia Opie, in her novel Adeline Mowbray (1804) wrote:
While the shopman was weighing the grapes, she saw a pine-apple on the counter, and felt a strong wish to carry it home as a more welcome present; but with unspeakable disappointment she heard that the price of it was two guineas—a sum which she could not think herself justified in expending, in the present state of their finances, even to please Glenmurray, especially as he had not expressed a wish for such an indulgence; besides, he liked grapes; and, as medicine, neither of them could be effectual.
This was the equivalent of around £2,0006 ($2,700) in today’s terms and so if you couldn’t afford to buy a pineapple, you could rent one, How did this work? Simple – you would put your rented pineapple in the middle of your dinner table for the guests to gawp at, and admire your taste and discernment, then you’d send it back the next morning (or, indeed, even sooner)! Alexis Soyer amusingly describes this in The Modern Housewife (1849):
“And, talk about pine-apples,” said he, “many times I have had the pleasure of meeting with the same, and even as much as twice in less than twelve hours, quite in a different direction, that is, on a dinner-table in the west-end about eight in the evening, and, at midnight, on the supper-table of a civic ball; at dinner being perched on an elevated stand in the centre of a large wide table, so much out of reach that it would almost require a small ladder to get at it; and I must say that every guest present paid due respect to his high position, and never made an assault, or even an attempt to disturb, much less to uncrown his fruity majesty, though, now and then, one of the fair guests, as a compliment, would remark to the amphitrion, that she never saw in her life a finer pine-apple. ‘Very fine, very fine indeed, madam! will you allow me to offer you part of an orange?’ ‘Not any more, I thank you, sir,’ being the reply.”
On the supper table this aristocratic and inaccessible pine still holds its kingly rank, and is still proudly perched on the top of a sideboard, surrounded by Portugal or Rhenish grapes, and to prevent its dethronement by removing the grapes the intelligent waiter has carefully tied it to the ornament that supports it. Our friend, who is a literary gentleman, has promised to write a small brochure, to be called the ‘Memoirs of a Pineapple in London,’ which I am confident, will not fail of being very interesting, having had the advantage of mixing in so many different societies.
The introduction of the steamship in the 19th century enabled pineapples to be imported from the West Indies for consumption in Europe, ripening en route with little spoilage. While still luxuries, they became more widely accessible to the middle classes and with further improvements in shipping and refrigeration in the 20th century they became with in the reach of almost everyone.
As Jess will also be making pizza today, and to link back to my previous post, I’ll end by talking a little bit about that most contentious dish, the Hawaiian pizza. First off, it wasn’t concocted in Hawaii, rather in the Satellite Restaurant, Chatham, Ontario, Canada, in 1962. The inventor, Greek-born Sam Panopoulos, was messing around with new pizza ideas with his brothers and decided to put some tinned pineapple ('Hawaiian’ pineapple, hence the name of the pizza) together with some ham on a pizza. As Sam told the BBC in 2017:
We just put it on, just for the fun of it, see how it was going to taste. We were young in the business and we were doing a lot of experiments.
We tried it first, passed it to some customers, and a couple of months later, they're going crazy about it. So we put it on the menu.
To say that this creation has caused controversy is putting it mildly. In 2017 the president of Iceland, Guðni Th. Jóhannesson, stated: “I would ban pineapple pizza if I could.” This caused Canadian prime minister, Justin Trudeau, to retort: “I have a pineapple. I have a pizza. And I stand behind this delicious Southwestern Ontario creation.”
The debate rages on to this day. Some people love it. Some people hate it. Whatever your opinion it could not have existed without centuries of history.
Happy birthday for tomorrow, Jess!
Of course the Vikings had previously arrived in North America and occupied L’Anse aux Meadows around the year 1000, but they didn’t encounter pineapples.
Yes, I am aware of the account in Peter Martyr d’Anghiera’s De Orbe Novo of the King being presented with a pineapple, and there is contextual mention of him being delighted by tasting fruits, but it is not clear that he was actually eating the pineapple.
I would treat this figure with a degree of caution, it comes from secondary sources written in the early 19th century.
As I have mentioned in previous posts, equating historic sums to modern amounts is complex and there are various different methods. My personal view is that simply applying inflation under-calls it, and that the most effective approach in terms of understanding real value is to look at it in the context of average wages of the day, and compare those to their equivalents today.
I have seen reports that the sum was as high as £5,500!




Can you give me the page number for the citation from Cobbet's *Cottage Economy*? I've just gone all the way through the book and couldn't find it. Thanks!